Why our carbon emission policies don't work on air travel

Why our carbon emission policies don't work on air travel The Gillard government’s carbon price had no effect on the aviation industry. Shutterstock Francis Markham, Australian National University; Arianne C. Reis, Western Sydney University; James Higham, University of Otago, and Martin Young, Southern Cross University

The federal government’s National Energy Guarantee aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the electricity industry by 26% of 2005 levels. But for Australia to meet its Paris climate change commitments, this 26% reduction will need to be replicated economy-wide.

In sectors such as aviation this is going to be very costly, if not impossible. Our modelling of the carbon price introduced by the Gillard government shows it had no detectable effect on kilometres flown and hence carbon emitted, despite being levied at A$23-$24 per tonne.

If Australia is to meet its Paris climate commitments, the National Energy Guarantee target will need to be raised or radical measures will be required, such as putting a hard cap on emissions in sectors such as aviation.

Our analysis of domestic aviation found no correlation between the Gillard government’s carbon price and domestic air travel, even when adjusting statistically for other factors that influence the amount Australians fly.

This is despite the carbon price being very effective at reducing emissions in the energy sector.

To reduce aviation emissions, a carbon price must either make flying less carbon intensive, or make people fly less.

In theory, a carbon tax should improve carbon efficiency by increasing the costs of polluting technologies and systems, relative to less polluting alternatives. If this is not possible, a carbon price might reduce emissions by making air travel more expensive, thereby encouraging people to either travel less or use alternative modes of transport.

Why the carbon price failed to reduce domestic aviation

The cost of air travel has fallen dramatically over the last 25 years. As the chart below shows, economy air fares in Australia in 2018 are just 55% of the average cost in 1992 (after adjusting for inflation).

Given this dramatic reduction in fares, many consumers would not have noticed a small increase in prices due to the carbon tax. Qantas, for example, increased domestic fares by between A$1.82 and A$6.86.

The carbon price may have just been too small to reduce consumer demand - even when passed on to consumers in full.

Consumer demand may have actually been increased by the Clean Energy Future policy, which included household compensation.

The cost of jet fuel, which accounts for between 30 and 40% of total airline expenses, has fluctuated dramatically over the last decade.

As the chart below shows, oil were around USD$80-$100 per barrel during the period of the carbon price, but had fallen to around USD$50 per barrel just a year later.

Airlines manage these large fluctuations by absorbing the cost or passing them on through levies. Fare segmentation and dynamic pricing also make ticket prices difficult to predict and understand.

Compared to the volatility in the cost of fuel, the carbon price was negligible.

The carbon price was also unlikely to have been fully passed through to consumers as Virgin and Qantas were engaged in heavy competition at the time, also known as the “capacity wars”.

This saw airlines running flights at well below profitable passenger loads in order to gain market share. It also meant the airlines stopped passing on the carbon price to customers.

A carbon price could incentivise airlines to reduce emissions by improving their management systems or changing plane technology. But such an incentive already existed in 2012-2014, in the form of high fuel prices.

A carbon price would only provide an additional incentive over and above high fuel prices if there is an alternative, non-taxed form of energy to switch to. This is the case for electricity generators, who can switch to solar or wind power.

But more efficient aeroplane materials, engines and biofuels are more myth than reality.

What would meeting Australia’s Paris commitment require?

Given the failure of the carbon price to reduce domestic air travel, there are two possibilities to reduce aviation emissions by 26% on 2005 levels.

The first is to insist on reducing emissions across all industry sectors. In the case of aviation, the modest A$23-$24 per tonne carbon price did not work.

Hard caps on emissions will be needed. Given the difficulty of technological change, this will require that people fly less.

The second option is to put off reducing aviation emissions and take advantage of more viable sources of emissions reduction elsewhere.

By increasing the National Energy Guarantee target to well above 26%, the emission reductions in the energy sector could offset a lack of progress in aviation. This is the most economically efficient way to reduce economy-wide emissions, but does little to reduce carbon pollution from aviation specifically.

Airline emissions are likely to remain a difficult problem, but one that needs to be tackled if we’re to stay within habitable climate limits.The Conversation

About The Author

Francis Markham, Research Fellow, College of Arts and Social Sciences, Australian National University; Arianne C. Reis, Senior lecturer, Western Sydney University; James Higham, Professor of Tourism, University of Otago, and Martin Young, Associate Professor, School of Business and Tourism, Southern Cross University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Related Books

enafarzh-CNzh-TWnltlfrdehiiditjakomsfaptruesswsvthtrurvi

LATEST VIDEOS

A Climate Reckoning In The Heartland
by CBS News
"A historic flood in March 2019 left much of America's heartland under water. Partiularly hard-hit were Midwestern…
What Would Happen If Antarctica Melted?
by Put Put 1
"What Would Happen If Antarctica Melted?
Dr. Peter Wadhams: Arctic Research & the Methane Risk
by UPFSI
Peter Wadhams is back on ScientistsWarning.TV with a comprehensive analysis of the reticent approach that part of the…
As Temperatures Soar, A ‘Heat Dome’ Is Coming To The Arctic
by PBS NewsHour
After Europe experienced record-breaking temperatures this month, climate scientists are now concerned that a heat wave…
Why Science Needs The Humanities To Solve Climate Change
Why Science Needs The Humanities To Solve Climate Change
by Steven D. Allison and Tyrus Miller
Large wildfires in the Arctic and intense heat waves in Europe are just the latest evidence that climate change is…
How 2030 is the new 2100: Global Food Yields Already Dropping from Abrupt Climate Change
by Paul Beckwith
2030 is the new 2100. Climate change is ALREADY reducing global food yields TODAY, with an average 1% annual reduction…
Why The US Has No High-Speed Rail
by CNBC
China has the world’s fastest and largest high-speed rail network — more than 19,000 miles, the vast majority of which…
Extreme Weather Caused By Climate Change Has Damaged 45% Of Australia's Coastal Habitat
Extreme Weather Caused By Climate Change Has Damaged 45% Of Australia's Coastal Habitat
by Russ Babcock, et al
If you think climate change is only gradually affecting our natural systems, think again.

LATEST ARTICLES

IPCC's Land Report Shows The Problem With Farming Based Around Oil, Not Soil
IPCC's Land Report Shows The Problem With Farming Based Around Oil, Not Soil
by Anna Krzywoszynska
The word “climate” makes most of us look up to the sky – however, the IPCC’s new special report on climate change and…
Climate Change Will Mean More Multiyear Snow Droughts In The West
Climate Change Will Mean More Multiyear Snow Droughts In The West
by Adrienne Marshall
As an environmental scientist, I’ve done plenty of hiking in the western U.S. – always with a map, water bottle and…
European Union Helped To Cool 2003 Heatwave
European Union Helped To Cool 2003 Heatwave
by Tim Radford
Small local changes make a big difference as the temperature soars. And the European Union’s existence once cooled a…
Balkan Water Reserves May Soon Run Short
Balkan Water Reserves May Soon Run Short
by Kieran Cooke
South-east Europe faces problems in the next decade as Balkan water reserves are expected to falter, imperilling…
Climate-driven Extreme Weather Is Threatening Old Bridges With Collapse
Climate-driven Extreme Weather Is Threatening Old Bridges With Collapse
by Maria Pregnolato and Elizabeth Lewis,
The recent collapse of a bridge in Grinton, North Yorkshire, raises lots of questions about how prepared we are for…
Giant Sandscaping Plan To Save Norfolk Coast Will Only Put Off The Inevitable
Giant Sandscaping Plan To Save Norfolk Coast Will Only Put Off The Inevitable
by Sally Brown
This summer, the UK’s Norfolk coast is undergoing a transformation that has only been seen once in the world before.
Can We Really Restore Or Protect Natural Habitats To Offset Those We Destroy?
Can We Really Restore Or Protect Natural Habitats To Offset Those We Destroy?
by Sophus zu Ermgassen and Joseph William Bull
In the forests of northern Sweden, a major train line cuts through land originally protected for migratory birds – so…
Wicked Problems and How To Solve Them
by Ana Carolina de Almeida Kumlien and Paul Coughlan
Wicked problems are issues so complex and dependent on so many factors that it is hard to grasp what exactly the…