How Geo-Engineered Crops May Help And Harm

To cool the world and also boost plant growth, geo-engineered crops might do the trick. But if they work by dimming the sunlight, the plants will suffer.

Proposals to tackle climate change that rely on geo-engineered crops show neatly the double bind that can await remedies which try to do too much.

US researchers have cast yet another shadow over the hopes of those who think global technology could damp down global warming. A worldwide manmade sunscreen might limit distress to crops from heat extremes, but on the other hand the drop in solar radiation would be just as damaging.

The message: there is still no easy technological answer to the challenge of global warming and climate change.

Scientists report in the journal Nature that they studied two well-documented events in which nature itself conducted a form of geoengineering. One was the eruption of El Chichon in Mexico in 1982, and the other was the explosion of Pinatubo in the Philippines in 1991.

Suggesting a remedy

Pinatubo ejected a spectacular 20 million tons of sulphate aerosols into the upper atmosphere to reduce sunlight by 2.5% and to lower global average temperatures by around 0.5 C.

Such eruptions seemed to suggest a possible method for managing global warming, The deliberate release of aerosols into the stratosphere could, some scientists argued, counter the threat of global warming from ever greater emissions of greenhouse gases as a consequence of the ever more extensive combustion of fossil fuels.

And global warming certainly presents a global danger to food supplies: researchers have repeatedly shown that, as temperatures soar, crop yields suffer.

The researchers then asked the question: what happens to crops when sunlight is scattered back into space? They analysed the levels of aerosols, all the available data for solar irradiation, and the statistics for crop yields for 105 countries from 1979 to 2009, to find that as the sunlight bounced back into space in 1982 and 1991, yields from rice, soy, wheat and maize all suffered.

“Sunlight powers everything on the planet, so we must understand the possible outcomes if we are going to try to manage it”

A bit more work with computer simulations showed them that losses from reductions in sunlight would match any benefits crops might gain from a cooler climate. Intentional geo-engineering would fail to deliver the hoped-for extra food on the global table.

“Shading the planet keeps things cooler, which helps crops grow better. But plants also need sunlight to grow, so blocking sunlight can affect growth. For agriculture, the unintended impacts of solar geo-engineering are equal in magnitude to the benefits,” said lead author Jonathan Proctor, a doctoral candidate at the University of California, Berkeley.

“It’s a bit like performing an experimental surgery; the side-effects of treatment appear to be as bad as the illness.”

Researchers have repeatedly examined
geo-engineering solutions to the challenge of climate change. Humans have inadvertently warmed the planet. So surely they could intentionally cool it again with some ambitious technology, the reasoning goes.

Recurrent snags

But almost every examination of the potential benefits and handicaps of such an approach has been discouraging: either the technology won’t deliver benefits, or it could prove harmful in unexpected ways.

Partners in the latest study include Solomon Hsiang of UC Berkeley and Marshall Burke of Stanford University. In the past few years the two have looked closely at the economic and social consequences of global warming, to find that temperature increases are likely to affect many people’s incomes; that as the thermometer rises, so does the danger of social conflict, and even of depression and suicide.

“Unknown unknowns make everybody nervous when it comes to global policies, as they should,” Professor Hsiang said. “The problem in figuring out the consequences of solar geo-engineering is that we can’t do a planetary-scale experiment without actually deploying the technology.

Learning from nature

“The breakthrough here was realising that we could learn something by studying the effects of giant volcanic eruptions that geo-engineering tries to copy.”

Sunscreen by sulphate aerosol is not the only possible geo-engineering solution; and food security is not the only thing threatened by rising temperatures. The latest study is unlikely to be the end of the debate. The authors suggest more research into the human and ecological consequences of geo-engineering, both good and bad.

“The most certain way to reduce damages to crops and, in turn, people’s livelihood and well-being, is reducing carbon emissions,” Proctor said. And Professor Hsiang said: “Perhaps what is most important is that we have respect for the potential scale, power and risks of geo-engineering technologies.

“Sunlight powers everything on the planet, so we must understand the possible outcomes if we are going to try to manage it.” – Climate News Network

About the Author

Tim Radford, freelance journalistTim Radford is a freelance journalist. He worked for The Guardian for 32 years, becoming (among other things) letters editor, arts editor, literary editor and science editor. He won the Association of British Science Writers award for science writer of the year four times. He served on the UK committee for the International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction. He has lectured about science and the media in dozens of British and foreign cities. 

Science that Changed the World: The untold story of the other 1960s revolutionBook by this Author:

Science that Changed the World: The untold story of the other 1960s revolution
by Tim Radford.

Click here for more info and/or to order this book on Amazon. (Kindle book)

Related Books

English Afrikaans Arabic Chinese (Simplified) Chinese (Traditional) Dutch Filipino French German Hindi Indonesian Italian Japanese Korean Malay Persian Portuguese Russian Spanish Swahili Swedish Thai Turkish Urdu Vietnamese

LATEST VIDEOS

Why Climate Change Will Dull Autumn Leaf Displays
Why Climate Change Will Dull Autumn Leaf Displays
by Matthew Brookhouse
Every autumn we are treated to one of nature’s finest seasonal annual transitions: leaf colour change and fall.
Climate denial isn’t stopping climate action.
by David Wallace-Wells
Climate change denial draws headlines. But is it actually an obstacle to climate action? A great majority of Americans…
Noam Chomsky: The Green New Deal Is Exactly the Right Idea
by Democracy Now!
Supporters of the Green New Deal are launching a nationwide tour Thursday to build support for the congressional…
Sea Creatures Store Carbon In The Ocean – Could Protecting Them Help Slow Climate Change?
Sea Creatures Store Carbon In The Ocean – Could Protecting Them Help Slow Climate Change?
by Heidi Pearson
As the prospect of catastrophic effects from climate change becomes increasingly likely, a search is on for innovative…
Rise of The Methane; Latest Science on Temporal and Spatial Variations
by Paul Beckwith
Since 2007 atmospheric methane concentrations have risen strongly; average rate 7 ppb per year. Methane’s…
A Message from the Future with AOC: New Film Imagines World Transformed by the Green New Deal
by Democracy Now!
As the push for the Green New Deal builds momentum in the United States, The Intercept has released a short illustrated…
How Nepal’s Rivers Give Green Power To Remote Areas
How Nepal’s Rivers Give Green Power To Remote Areas
by Duke University
Researchers are investigating a method of creating power from fast moving streams that many rural areas in Nepal use.
Why the ocean you know and love won’t exist in 50 years
by David Wallace Wells, Big Think
Coral reefs may not be able to survive another human decade because of the environmental stress we have placed on them,…

LATEST ARTICLES

How Alberta Grizzly Bears Will Feel The Effects Of Climate Change
How Alberta Grizzly Bears Will Feel The Effects Of Climate Change
by Greg McDermid, et al
Toward the end of each summer, grizzly bears in Alberta’s Rocky Mountains gorge on the tart red berries of a shrub…
Is There An Electrical Meltdown In Our Future: If So, How Could We Avert Disaster?
Is There An Electrical Meltdown In Our Future?
by Keith Harary
You might find your car dying on the freeway while other vehicles around you lose control and crash.
Why Climate Change Will Dull Autumn Leaf Displays
Why Climate Change Will Dull Autumn Leaf Displays
by Matthew Brookhouse
Every autumn we are treated to one of nature’s finest seasonal annual transitions: leaf colour change and fall.
Climate denial isn’t stopping climate action.
by David Wallace-Wells
Climate change denial draws headlines. But is it actually an obstacle to climate action? A great majority of Americans…
How Rain On Other Side Of The Planet Foreshadows California Heat
How Rain On Other Side Of The Planet Foreshadows California Heat
by Kat Kerlin
When heavy rain falls over the Indian Ocean and Southeast Asia and the eastern Pacific Ocean, it is a good indicator…
Noam Chomsky: The Green New Deal Is Exactly the Right Idea
by Democracy Now!
Supporters of the Green New Deal are launching a nationwide tour Thursday to build support for the congressional…
Australia’s Epic Story Is A Tale Of Amazing People, Amazing Creatures And Rising Seas
Australia’s Epic Story Is A Tale Of Amazing People, Amazing Creatures And Rising Seas
by Michael Bird, et al
The Australian continent has a remarkable history — a story of isolation, desiccation and resilience on an ark at the…
Sea Creatures Store Carbon In The Ocean – Could Protecting Them Help Slow Climate Change?
Sea Creatures Store Carbon In The Ocean – Could Protecting Them Help Slow Climate Change?
by Heidi Pearson
As the prospect of catastrophic effects from climate change becomes increasingly likely, a search is on for innovative…