Why Sustainability Rankings Don't Always Identify Sustainable Companies

Why Sustainability Rankings Don't Always Identify Sustainable Companies ESG rankings and lists aren’t often entirely reliable for consumers or investors wanting to make decisions on companies they buy from or invest in. Appolinary Kalashnikova/Unsplash

British American Tobacco (famous for cigarettes), Coca-Cola (world-renowned for its sugary soft drinks) and Glencore (a British/Swiss mining company) were recently ranked in the top five most environmentally and socially responsible companies on the FTSE 100, the share index of the 100 biggest companies listed on the London Stock Exchange.

As consumers and investors, we often look at environmental, social and governance (ESG) rankings to guide our purchase, investment and employment decisions. But what should we make of this list, compiled by British investment services firm Hargreaves Lansdown?

As kids, we learned that smoking kills, yet British American Tobacco has a place at the top of the list, suggesting it’s a highly responsible company.

Obesity, cardiovascular disease and diabetes are life-threatening diseases, yet Coca Cola, a leading sugar purveyor, also has a top ranking.

Why Sustainability Rankings Don't Always Identify Sustainable Companies A tractor trailer truck backs into a loading dock at Coca-Cola Beverages Florida past a Now Hiring sign in May 2020, in Hollywood, Fla. (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee)

Glencore is being investigated for alleged fraud offences, yet it’s No. 4 on the same list.

Meaningless?

A number of lists rank companies as being “most responsible” or the “best corporate citizens” or the “most green.”

The Corporate Knights Global 100, for example, is an annual list that evaluates companies based on their sustainability performance. Companies are given a score based on their environmental, social, governance and economic performance and then ranked from one to 100.

Newsweek magazine’s America’s Most Responsible Company list also ranks U.S. companies on their sustainability performance.

Its 2021 list ranked Citigroup as the country’s ninth most responsible firm. The bank was recently fined US$400 million by federal regulators for “unsafe and unsound banking practices.”

Microsoft is ranked third on the same list, yet earlier this year, 250 million client records were exposed online without password protection.

Procter & Gamble, 23rd on the Newsweek list, is currently being scrutinized for its reliance on trees from Canada’s northern boreal forest.

In Canada, Corporate Knights ranks Canada’s Best 50 corporate citizens. Leading the pack is Mountain Equipment Co-op, which recently apologized for the lack of diversity in a marketing campaign that excluded people of colour.

Hydro One, in the No. 11 position, has been taken to task for its executive compensation packages.

Consumers, investors look at rankings

Increasing numbers of investors depend on ESG information from third parties for their investment decisions. Similarly, consumers are seeking sustainable products and looking to responsible firms to inform their purchasing decisions.

There are also an increasing number of companies entering the ESG rankings field. Currently there is no regulatory oversight or consistency across ranking agencies on what factors are being assessed in the rankings and who is assessing them.

As well, there are no global or nationally accepted standards or consistent requirements on what should be reported or measured for ESG performance. Companies are evaluated based on a wide range of criteria, making it challenging for consumers and investors to make fully informed decisions.

Should investors look at ESG ratings to assess their investment choices and the associated risks?

We looked at the top five Canadian firms from Corporate Knights 2020 Global 100 list and searched the Sustainalytics ESG Risk Database to see their ESG risk. Sustainalytics, a company initially launched in Canada as Jantzi Research, measures a company’s exposure to industry-specific ESG risks and how well a company is managing those risks, as well as the extent of any unmanaged ESG risk.

Three Canadian companies — the Bank of Montreal, Cascades and Canadian National Railway — were ranked as low risk, while two, Algonquin and Bombardier, which placed even higher on the Corporate Knights Global 100 list than the three aforementioned companies, are considered high risk by the Sustainalytics ESG Risk rating.

No consistency

Why would one well-known ESG ranking agency rate a company a leader while another flag it as high risk? If all the ratings and rankings are measuring ESG, we would anticipate consistency across rankings.

While rankings should help us in our quest to make better, more sustainable decisions and choose ethical companies as consumers and investors, they can be misleading and provide only a partial view of a company’s ESG commitments.

When determining which rankings to trust, we suggest looking for ranking agencies that use public information to assess companies on ESG performance. Quality ranking organizations are transparent about how they analyze companies and come up with their rankings. Those reading the lists should be able to assess the information provided in the ranking quickly and with confidence about what it really says.

Look for rankings that don’t accept payment from companies to participate; this reduces their power to influence their placement. Look at information from multiple rankings and ratings.

When companies in contested industries (those that do harm) score high in sustainability rankings, it should raise serious questions about the validity of the ranking.

Rather than blindly trusting rankings, understand the information provided by each list. While rankings are designed to offer compressed information, unfortunately, we still need to do our own research to evaluate companies.The Conversation

About The Author

Rumina Dhalla, Associate Professor, Organizational Studies and Sustainable Commerce and Director, Institute for Sustainable Commerce, University of Guelph and Felix Arndt, John F. Wood Chair in Entrepreneurship, University of Guelph

Related Books

Climate Leviathan: A Political Theory of Our Planetary Future

by Joel Wainwright and Geoff Mann
1786634295How climate change will affect our political theory—for better and worse. Despite the science and the summits, leading capitalist states have not achieved anything close to an adequate level of carbon mitigation. There is now simply no way to prevent the planet breaching the threshold of two degrees Celsius set by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. What are the likely political and economic outcomes of this? Where is the overheating world heading? Available On Amazon

Upheaval: Turning Points for Nations in Crisis

by Jared Diamond
0316409138Adding a psychological dimension to the in-depth history, geography, biology, and anthropology that mark all of Diamond's books, Upheaval reveals factors influencing how both whole nations and individual people can respond to big challenges. The result is a book epic in scope, but also his most personal book yet. Available On Amazon

Global Commons, Domestic Decisions: The Comparative Politics of Climate Change

by Kathryn Harrison et al
0262514311Comparative case studies and analyses of the influence of domestic politics on countries' climate change policies and Kyoto ratification decisions. Climate change represents a “tragedy of the commons” on a global scale, requiring the cooperation of nations that do not necessarily put the Earth's well-being above their own national interests. And yet international efforts to address global warming have met with some success; the Kyoto Protocol, in which industrialized countries committed to reducing their collective emissions, took effect in 2005 (although without the participation of the United States). Available On Amazon

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

enafarzh-CNzh-TWdanltlfifrdeiwhihuiditjakomsnofaplptruesswsvthtrukurvi

follow InnerSelf on

facebook icontwitter iconyoutube iconinstagram iconpintrest iconrss icon

 Get The Latest By Email

Weekly Magazine Daily Inspiration

POLITICS

UK Court Urged To Respect 1.5°c Climate Limit
UK Court Urged To Respect 1.5°c Climate Limit
by Alex Kirby
The UK faces growing pressure not to expand Heathrow airport but to respect the 1.5°C limit agreed on global heating.
Why Sustainability Rankings Don't Always Identify Sustainable Companies
Why Sustainability Rankings Don't Always Identify Sustainable Companies
by Rumina Dhalla and Felix Arndt, University of Guelph
As consumers and investors, we often look at environmental, social and governance (ESG) rankings to guide our purchase,…
How To Stop Psychopaths and Narcissists From Winning Positions of Power
How To Stop Psychopaths and Narcissists From Winning Positions of Power
by Steve Taylor, Leeds Beckett University
In the past, this was mostly due to hereditary systems which assigned power to kings and lords and others, who often…
How Children Are Taking European States To Court Over The Climate Crisis – And Changing The Law
How Children Are Taking European States To Court Over The Climate Crisis – And Changing The Law
by Aoife Daly, University College Cork et al
Even before Greta Thunberg launched her school strike for climate at age 15, youth activists have been key players in…
If 80% Of Australians Care About Climate Action, Why Don't They Vote Like It?
If 80% Of Australians Care About Climate Action, Why Don't They Vote Like It?
by Rebecca Colvin and Frank Jotzo, Australian National University
Poll after poll suggests a large majority of Australians cares about climate change. Yet in recent federal elections,…
Keeping Hope Of 1.5°c Limit Alive Is Vital To Spurring Global Climate Action
Keeping Hope Of 1.5°c Limit Alive Is Vital To Spurring Global Climate Action
by Richard Black, Imperial College London and Catherine Happer, University of Glasgow
Ever since governments at the 2015 Paris climate summit set 1.5°C as the desired limit for global warming, scientists…
Lawmakers and Groups Demand Urgent Action by Fed to Protect Economy From Climate Risks
Lawmakers and Groups Demand Urgent Action by Fed to Protect Economy From Climate Risks
by Jessica Corbett
The Federal Reserve must do its job, steering the economy away from disaster by ending fossil fuel finance.
Fossil Fuel Companies Got $8.2 Billion in Tax Bailouts—Then Fired Over 58,000 Workers
Fossil Fuel Companies Got $8.2 Billion in Tax Bailouts—Then Fired Over 58,000 Workers
by Jessica Corbett
It's time to stop subsidizing them and start facing the climate crisis, says a BailoutWatch analyst.

LATEST VIDEOS

The Last Ice Age Tells Us Why We Need To Care About A 2℃ Change In Temperature
The Last Ice Age Tells Us Why We Need To Care About A 2℃ Change In Temperature
by Alan N Williams, et al
The latest report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) states that without a substantial decrease…
Earth Has Stayed Habitable For Billions Of Years – Exactly How Lucky Did We Get?
Earth Has Stayed Habitable For Billions Of Years – Exactly How Lucky Did We Get?
by Toby Tyrrell
It took evolution 3 or 4 billion years to produce Homo sapiens. If the climate had completely failed just once in that…
How Mapping The Weather 12,000 Years Ago Can Help Predict Future Climate Change
How Mapping The Weather 12,000 Years Ago Can Help Predict Future Climate Change
by Brice Rea
The end of the last ice age, around 12,000 years ago, was characterised by a final cold phase called the Younger Dryas.…
The Caspian Sea Is Set To Fall By 9 Metres Or More This Century
The Caspian Sea Is Set To Fall By 9 Metres Or More This Century
by Frank Wesselingh and Matteo Lattuada
Imagine you are on the coast, looking out to sea. In front of you lies 100 metres of barren sand that looks like a…
Venus Was Once More Earth-like, But Climate Change Made It Uninhabitable
Venus Was Once More Earth-like, But Climate Change Made It Uninhabitable
by Richard Ernst
We can learn a lot about climate change from Venus, our sister planet. Venus currently has a surface temperature of…
Five Climate Disbeliefs: A Crash Course In Climate Misinformation
The Five Climate Disbeliefs: A Crash Course In Climate Misinformation
by John Cook
This video is a crash course in climate misinformation, summarizing the key arguments used to cast doubt on the reality…
The Arctic Hasn't Been This Warm For 3 Million Years and That Means Big Changes For The Planet
The Arctic Hasn't Been This Warm For 3 Million Years and That Means Big Changes For The Planet
by Julie Brigham-Grette and Steve Petsch
Every year, sea ice cover in the Arctic Ocean shrinks to a low point in mid-September. This year it measures just 1.44…
What Is A Hurricane Storm Surge and Why Is It So Dangerous?
What Is A Hurricane Storm Surge and Why Is It So Dangerous?
by Anthony C. Didlake Jr
As Hurricane Sally headed for the northern Gulf Coast on Tuesday, September 15, 2020, forecasters warned of a…

LATEST ARTICLES

How Bad Could Our Climate Future Be If We Do Nothing?
How Bad Could Our Climate Future Be If We Do Nothing?
by Mark Maslin, UCL
The climate crisis is no longer a looming threat – people are now living with the consequences of centuries of…
Wildfires Can Poison Drinking Water – Here's How Communities Can Be Better Prepared
Wildfires Can Poison Drinking Water – Here's How Communities Can Be Better Prepared
by Andrew J. Whelton and Caitlin R. Proctor, Purdue University
After the fires passed, testing ultimately revealed widespread hazardous drinking water contamination. Evidence…
Almost All The World’s Glaciers Are Shrinking—and Fast
Almost All The World’s Glaciers Are Shrinking—and Fast
by Peter Rüegg, ETH Zurich
A new study shows just how fast glaciers have lost thickness and mass over the past two decades.
Installing Solar Panels Over California's Canals Could Yield Water, Land, Air And Climate Payoffs
Installing Solar Panels Over California's Canals Could Yield Water, Land, Air And Climate Payoffs
by Roger Bales and Brandi McKuin, University of California
Climate change and water scarcity are front and center in the western U.S. The region’s climate is warming, a severe…
Changes In The Weather: El Niño and La Niña Explained
Changes In The Weather: El Niño and La Niña Explained
by Jaci Brown, CSIRO
We wait in anticipation of droughts and floods when El Niño and La Niña are forecast but what are these climatic events?
Mammals Face An Uncertain Future As Global Temperatures Rise
Mammals Face An Uncertain Future As Global Temperatures Rise
by Maria Paniw, and Rob Salguero-Gómez
Even with fires, droughts and floods regularly in the news, it’s difficult to comprehend the human toll of the climate…
Longer And More Frequent Droughts Are Hitting The Western US
Longer And More Frequent Droughts Are Hitting The Western US
by Rose Brandt, University of Arizona
Against the backdrop of steadily warming temperatures and decreasing annual rainfall totals, extreme-duration drought…
Farming Without Disturbing Soil Could Cut Agriculture's Climate Impact By 30%
Farming Without Disturbing Soil Could Cut Agriculture's Climate Impact By 30%
by Sacha Mooney, University of Nottingham et al
Perhaps because there are no chimney stacks belching smoke, the contribution of the world’s farms to climate change…

 Get The Latest By Email

Weekly Magazine Daily Inspiration

New Attitudes - New Possibilities

InnerSelf.comClimateImpactNews.com | InnerPower.net
MightyNatural.com | WholisticPolitics.com
Copyright ©1985 - 2021 InnerSelf Publications. All Rights Reserved.