Study Shows US Media Coverage of Right-Wing Think Tank Climate Lies Actually Rose Over Past 5 Years

Study Shows US Media Coverage of Right-Wing Think Tank Climate Lies Actually Rose Over Past 5 Years

The media should not give these organizations a platform, and if they must cover them, do a better job of alerting readers and viewers who is funding them.

In April of 2017, a demonstrator carries a sign labeling President Donald Trump a "climate denier" outside the Trump International Hotel in Washington, D.C. (Photo: Oil Change International/Twitter)

A new Public Citizen analysis shows that over the past five years—as rising global temperatures repeatedly set records—national television news networks and the 50 most widely circulated newspapers in the United States increased their coverage of right-wing think tanks denying the climate emergency or that the global crisis is the result of unsustainable human activity.

"The mounds of scientific evidence that the burning of fossil fuels is overheating our planet, coupled with the knowledge that the fossil fuel industry has funneled money to think tanks to manufacture doubt about the crisis should lead to a radical decline in the influence of climate deniers in the media."
—Allison Fisher, Public Citizen"Amazingly, coverage of the deniers' messages has risen over the past five years as the climate crisis has worsened, with much of it being uncritical," Allison Fisher, outreach program director for Public Citizen's climate program, said Thursday. "The media should not give these organizations a platform, and if they must cover them, do a better job of alerting readers and viewers who is funding them."

The consumer advocacy group released its new study ahead of the 13th annual conference of the Heartland Institute—the self-described "leading think tank promoting skepticism of the theory there is a human-caused climate crisis"—which kicked off at the Trump International Hotel in Washington, D.C. on Thursday.

The study focuses on coverage of the Heartland Institute and the four other think tanks associated with the conference—the American Enterprise Institute, the Competitive Enterprise Institute, the Cato Institute, and the Heritage Foundation—from 2014 through mid-June 2019.

According to Public Citizen:

The number of media mentions featuring the think tanks and published op-eds by them rose over the five years, hitting a peak in 2017 (in the wake of President Donald Trump's inauguration) and remaining steady over the course of 2018, Public Citizen found. Many outlets cited the deniers to provide "balance"—even though the deniers' positions have been widely debunked. Most outlets didn't inform viewers or readers that the think tanks receive fossil fuel money.

"The mounds of scientific evidence that the burning of fossil fuels is overheating our planet, coupled with the knowledge that the fossil fuel industry has funneled money to think tanks to manufacture doubt about the crisis," Fisher said, "should lead to a radical decline in the influence of climate deniers in the media."

Public Citizen analyzed transcripts from six television networks—ABC, CBS, CNN, Fox, MSNBC, and NBC—as well as articles and op-eds in newspapers that included the Atlanta Journal‐Constitution, The Boston Globe, the Chicago Sun‐Times, the Chicago Tribune, The Denver Post, the Detroit Free Press, the Houston Chronicle, the Los Angeles Times, the Miami Herald, the New York Post, The New York Times, the Philadelphia Inquirer, the San Francisco Chronicle, USA Today,The Wall Street Journal, and The Washington Post.

The analysis shows that across all 50 newspapers, the right-wing think tanks were cited or published a total of 528 times on the climate crisis. Only 17 percent of those mentions included an acknowledgement of the think tank's ties to the dirty energy sector, and 60 percent "presented arguments or comments by think tank representatives as legitimate views."

Of all the reviewed papers, The New York Times mentioned the think tanks the most—in 84 pieces over the five-year period. However, Public Citizen pointed out, "while 34 of those pieces provided false balance, the paper also published 17 pieces exposing climate denial and didn't publish any op-eds by the think tanks or by those citing the work of the think tanks."

The Wall Street Journal published the most op-eds of any newspaper—18 of the collective 84—and mentioned the think tanks 44 times. Public Citizen found that the majority of the mentions supported the think tank's position and only one Journal article acknowledged ties to the fossil fuel industry.

On the television side, Public Citizen documented 62 segments that featured the positions of or a representative from one of the think tanks. The large majority of segments—89 percent—aired on Fox News Network and CNN.

While all Fox segments "legitimized denier arguments," according to Public Citizen, more than half of CNN's segments included the denier perspective for "balance."

About The Author

Jessica Corbett is a staff writer for Common Dreams. Follow her on Twitter: @corbett_jessica.

This article originally appeared on Common Dreams

Related Books

Climate Leviathan: A Political Theory of Our Planetary Future

by Joel Wainwright and Geoff Mann
1786634295How climate change will affect our political theory—for better and worse. Despite the science and the summits, leading capitalist states have not achieved anything close to an adequate level of carbon mitigation. There is now simply no way to prevent the planet breaching the threshold of two degrees Celsius set by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. What are the likely political and economic outcomes of this? Where is the overheating world heading? Available On Amazon

Upheaval: Turning Points for Nations in Crisis

by Jared Diamond
0316409138Adding a psychological dimension to the in-depth history, geography, biology, and anthropology that mark all of Diamond's books, Upheaval reveals factors influencing how both whole nations and individual people can respond to big challenges. The result is a book epic in scope, but also his most personal book yet. Available On Amazon

Global Commons, Domestic Decisions: The Comparative Politics of Climate Change

by Kathryn Harrison et al
0262514311Comparative case studies and analyses of the influence of domestic politics on countries' climate change policies and Kyoto ratification decisions. Climate change represents a “tragedy of the commons” on a global scale, requiring the cooperation of nations that do not necessarily put the Earth's well-being above their own national interests. And yet international efforts to address global warming have met with some success; the Kyoto Protocol, in which industrialized countries committed to reducing their collective emissions, took effect in 2005 (although without the participation of the United States). Available On Amazon

enafarzh-CNzh-TWnltlfrdehiiditjakomsfaptruesswsvthtrurvi

POLITICS

Politics tops science under Trump
Politics Tops Science Under Trump
by Kieran Cooke
If you don’t like the news, then suppress it − because politics tops science in the US today, researchers are finding.
People Of Color Don’t Get Credit For Climate Concern
People Of Color Don’t Get Credit For Climate Concern
by U. Oregon
While their contributions to the climate change movement remain largely unrecognized, people of color are just as…
Talk About Loss To Boost Support For Environmental Causes
Talk About Loss To Boost Support For Environmental Causes
by Jim Logan
When it comes to garnering support for environmental causes, talking about the consequences of a loss works better than…
The Warspeak Permeating Everyday Language Puts Us All In The Trenches
The Warspeak Permeating Everyday Language Puts Us All In The Trenches
by Robert Myers
In a manifesto posted online shortly before he went on to massacre 22 people at an El Paso Walmart, Patrick Crusius…
Why Marianne Williamson's Candidacy for President Is Important
Why Marianne Williamson's Candidacy for President Is Important
How do you know something exists if you never hear about it? How do you know about the truth, which is often "the other…
Top Climate Scientist: I Put Myself Through Hell As An IPCC Convening Lead Author, But It Was Worth It
Top Climate Scientist: I Put Myself Through Hell As An IPCC Convening Lead Author, But It Was Worth It
by Pete Smith
In my day job, I am a scientist at the University of Aberdeen in Scotland studying things such as how agriculture…
Not Everyone Cares About Climate Change, But Reproach Won't Change Their Minds
Not Everyone Cares About Climate Change, But Reproach Won't Change Their Minds
by Chloe Lucas, et al
Contrary to opinion polls predicting a groundswell of support for Labor’s relatively progressive agenda on climate and…
Google Searches Reveal Where People Are Most Concerned About Climate Change
Google Searches Reveal Where People Are Most Concerned About Climate Change
by Carla Archibald and Nathalie Butt
What do you do if you have a question? You probably Google it.

LATEST VIDEOS

What Is The Future Of Climate Change?
by Simon Donner
You would think with all the chatter going on about climate that we’d all have a good understanding on the elements of…
Why Marianne Williamson's Candidacy for President Is Important
Why Marianne Williamson's Candidacy for President Is Important
How do you know something exists if you never hear about it? How do you know about the truth, which is often "the other…
Would You Eat Meat Grown From Cells In A Laboratory? Here's How It Works
Would You Eat Meat Grown From Cells In A Laboratory? Here's How It Works
by Leigh Ackland
For many of us, eating a meal containing meat is a normal part of daily life. But if we dig deeper, some sobering…
Climate System “Getting Unhinged” as Massive Heat Wave Causes Record Melting of Greenland Ice Sheet
by Democracy Now!
The massive heat dome that shattered all-time temperature records across much of Europe last week has settled in over…
Why We're Heading For A Climate Catastrophe
by BBC Newsnight
Scientists say the world is completely off track.
A Climate Reckoning In The Heartland
by CBS News
"A historic flood in March 2019 left much of America's heartland under water. Partiularly hard-hit were Midwestern…
What Would Happen If Antarctica Melted?
by Put Put 1
"What Would Happen If Antarctica Melted?
Dr. Peter Wadhams: Arctic Research & the Methane Risk
by UPFSI
Peter Wadhams is back on ScientistsWarning.TV with a comprehensive analysis of the reticent approach that part of the…

LATEST ARTICLES

Global Temps Continue To Soar Upward As NOAA Confirms July 2019 Was Hottest Month Since Records Began In 1880
Global Temps Continue To Soar Upward As NOAA Confirms July 2019 Was Hottest Month Since Records Began In 1880
by Julia Conley
As climate scientists raise alarm over hotter and hotter global temperatures, a top U.S. weather agency reported on…
Small Nuclear War Could Bring On Global Cooling
Small Nuclear War Could Bring On Global Cooling
by Tim Radford
Smoke from Canadian forest fires was so vast it bore comparison with a nuclear bomb’s mushroom cloud – and the global…
Still Sneezing? Climate Change May Prolong Allergy Season
Still Sneezing? Climate Change May Prolong Allergy Season
by Cecilia Sierra-Heredia, et al
Every year, without fail, summer brings changes to our surroundings: more sunlight, heat, greenness and flowers, among…
Pacific Island Nations Will No Longer Stand For Australia's Inaction On Climate Change
Pacific Island Nations Will No Longer Stand For Australia's Inaction On Climate Change
by Michael O'Keefe
The Pacific Islands Forum meeting in Tuvalu this week has ended in open division over climate change.
Ocean Warming Has Fisheries On The Move, Helping Some But Hurting More
Ocean Warming Has Fisheries On The Move, Helping Some But Hurting More
by InnerSelf Staff
Climate change has been steadily warming the ocean, which absorbs most of the heat trapped by greenhouse gases in the…
Politics tops science under Trump
Politics Tops Science Under Trump
by Kieran Cooke
If you don’t like the news, then suppress it − because politics tops science in the US today, researchers are finding.
Fossil Fuel Drilling Could Be Contributing To Climate Change By Heating Earth From Within
Fossil Fuel Drilling Could Be Contributing To Climate Change By Heating Earth From Within
by Rizwan Nawaz and Adel Sharif
Almost all scientists agree that burning fossil fuels is contributing to climate change. But agreement is less clear…
A Virtual Reality Field Trip Through South Florida's Everglades
A Virtual Reality Field Trip Through South Florida's Everglades
by Elizabeth (Liz) Miller
Before cities there were swamps. Wetlands and swamps globally have been sacrificed to pave the way for housing,…