Why Trump Is Confused On The Climate’s Security Threat

Why Trump Is Confused On The Climate’s Security Threat

The new US national defense strategy appears to leave President Trump in two minds on the risk from climate’s security threat.

Confused about climate’s security threat? Don’t worry – you’re not the only one. Donald Trump seems to be having great difficulty in knowing what to make of it too.

He’s even explicitly contradicted a senior colleague – and himself. And he’s prompted suggestions from retired military officers that America’s armed forces will continue to prepare for the reality of climate change undeterred.

The Trump administration has dropped climate change from a list of global threats in a new National Security Strategy the president has launched.

Instead, President Trump’s NSS emphasises the need for the US to regain its economic competitiveness in the world, with his “America First” plan focussing on four themes surrounding economic security for the US.

America first

The Associated Press lists them as “protecting the homeland and way of life; promoting American prosperity; demonstrating peace through strength; and advancing American influence in an ever-competitive world”.

“Climate change is not identified as a national security threat, but climate and the importance of the environment and environmental stewardship are discussed,” a senior administration official told the London Guardian. Last June the president announced his intention to withdraw the US from the Paris Agreement on climate change.

By contrast, former President Obama said that “climate change constitutes a serious threat to global security, an immediate risk to our national security. And make no mistake, it will impact how our military defends our country.”

The new doctrine is hard to reconcile with a statement by a man Mr Trump himself appointed to high office, the US Defense Secretary, Jim Mattis, who said in March that climate change was affecting stability in parts of the world where American troops were operating, and that it was appropriate for commanders to plan for the instability it would cause.

“We have a responsibility to prepare, and that’s becoming clearer every day”

The US Government Accountability Office said recently that military authorities are neglecting to plan for climate risks. A GAO study team said that of 45 military installations worldwide, only a third had integrated climate change adaptation into their planning.

Dozens of bases were exempted from a department-wide climate vulnerability assessment, including “key national security sites.” The report said the Pentagon omitted a number of facilities without adequate explanation – in some cases it simply stated that there was no risk, but gave no reasons.

But the starkest contrast between the new strategy and the past appears to be the work of Donald Trump himself. On 12 December he signed into law the National Defense Authorization Act. Its provisions include requiring the Pentagon to report on how military installations and overseas staff may be vulnerable to climate change over the next two decades.

To make sure that nobody missed the point, the act stated explicitly: “Climate change is a direct threat to the national security of the United States.” But the president who signed that act now, one week later, thinks climate change is not a security threat worth the name.

Continued preparation

The Center for Climate & Security (CCS) is a US non-partisan policy institute of security and military experts (many of them high-ranking former members of the armed forces). It regards the threats of climate change and nuclear conflict as inseparably joined.

The co-founder and president of the CCS, Francesco Femia, told the Climate News Network: “It’s very unfortunate that climate change is not being explicitly addressed as a national security threat in the National Security Strategy . . .

“However, despite this strategy, which is more of a political document than anything else, I think the broader national security community in the US will continue to prepare for this challenge, as was made clear by the defense bill, and as has been made clear by the Department of Defense.

“We have a responsibility to prepare, and that’s becoming clearer every day.” – Climate News Network

About the Author

Alex Kirby is a British journalistAlex Kirby is a British journalist specializing in environmental issues. He worked in various capacities at the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) for nearly 20 years and left the BBC in 1998 to work as a freelance journalist. He also provides media skills training to companies, universities and NGOs. He is also currently the environmental correspondent for BBC News Online, and hosted BBC Radio 4's environment series, Costing the Earth. He also writes for The Guardian and Climate News Network. He also writes a regular column for BBC Wildlife magazine.

Related Books

Global Discontents: Conversations on the Rising Threats to Democracy (The American Empire Project)
Author: Noam Chomsky
Binding: Paperback
Publisher: Metropolitan Books
List Price: $18.00
Offers - Buy New From: $8.50 Used From: $6.01 Collectible From: $609.50
Buy Now

Emerging Security Threats in the Middle East: The Impact of Climate Change and Globalization
Author: Ashok Swain
Binding: Paperback
  • Rowman Littlefield

Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers
List Price: $38.00
Offers - Buy New From: $30.99 Used From: $29.78
Buy Now

Emergency Management: The American Experience 1900-2010, Second Edition
Binding: Hardcover
  • CRC Press

Publisher: Routledge
List Price: $50.95
Offers - Buy New From: $32.79 Used From: $25.52
Buy Now



More Americans Agree On Going Green Than You Might Think
by Melissa De Witte
While the United States is deeply divided on many issues, there is remarkable consensus on climate change, according to…
The Political Split On Climate Change Isn’t So Wide After All
by Shelly Leachman
Just how far apart are Republicans and Democrats when it comes to views on climate change? Not all that far, a new…
We're Climate Researchers And Our Work Was Turned Into Fake News
by Michael Grubb, UCL
Science is slow. It rests on painstaking research with accumulating evidence. This makes for an inherently uneasy…
Here’s How Much Money The Mercer Family Donated To Climate Misinformation Groups In 2016
by Zahra Hirji, BuzzFeed
The Mercer family, among President Trump’s most powerful donors, in 2016 gave nearly $4 million to groups that…
Why The Doomsday Clock Puts World Risk At 65-year High
by Alex Kirby, Climate News Ntwork
The Doomsday Clock, a measure by scientists of the risk to global survival, now says the danger is the greatest since…
Why Trump Is Confused On The Climate’s Security Threat
by Alex Kirby, Climate News Network
The new US national defense strategy appears to leave President Trump in two minds on the risk from climate’s security…
People Report The Most Stress About This Climate Worry
by Alexis Blue-University of Arizona
While some people have little anxiety about the Earth’s changing climate, others are experiencing high levels of…
A Year Of Trump: How His Incendiary Style Took The Place Of Substance
by Clodagh Harrington, De Montfort University
Anyone looking for a visual representation of Donald Trump’s first year in office need only behold Time magazine’s…


How Geo-Engineered Crops May Help And Harm
by Tim Radford,Climate News Network
To cool the world and also boost plant growth, geo-engineered crops might do the trick. But if they work by dimming the…
Scientists Have Known Burning Coal Warms The Climate For A Long Time.
by Joe Romm, Think Progress
On August 14, 1912, a New Zealand newspaper’s “science notes and news” section ran a blurb headlined, “Coal consumption…
The Best Medicine for My Climate Grief
by Peter Kalmus
A climate scientist talks to a psychologist about coping with the crushing stress related to climate change. Here’s…
Climate Models Predict The World Will Be Anomalously Warm Until 2022
by Florian Sévellec
We developed a new prediction system we call PROCAST (PROabilistic foreCAST), and used it to predict the natural…
Holy Dog, It's "Hot As Spain!"
by Robert Jennings, InnerSelf.com
Now it's so hot in Europe that dogs are having to wear shoes. While a nice sunny day may seem like the perfect time for…
Why Forest Carbon Emissions Are Set To Grow
by Tim Radford, Climate News Network
The tropical forests could be at growing risk from climate change. And as they die, rising forest carbon emissions…
Is Climate Change Really To Blame For Slower Atlantic Circulation
by Hannah Hickey
Global warming isn’t the cause of slowdown in a huge circulation pattern in the Atlantic Ocean, which is, in fact, part…
Pantheism And How It Could Offer A New Approach To Preserving The Planet
by Tim Lomas
The scientists responsible for the “doomsday clock” moved it 30 seconds closer to midnight – the symbolic point of…